Deadly sin III of VII · Verdigris

Envy: the deadly sin of invidia

Another person’s good news, felt as your loss.

Updated · Checked against primary sources

Envy (Latin invidia) is the deadly sin of feeling sorrow at another person’s good and wanting them not to have it. Unlike most sins it gives no pleasure: it is pain at someone else’s happiness. Its opposite virtue is kindness, the ability to rejoice in other people’s good.

What is the sin of envy?

Envy was not on Evagrius’s original list of eight; Gregory the Great added it around 590, and Aquinas later defined it as “sorrow for another’s good”. Its Latin name comes from in-videre, to look upon, with the evil eye. Fittingly, in Dante’s Purgatorio the envious sit propped against each other with their eyelids sewn shut with iron wire, so they can no longer look at what others have.

Signs of envy in everyday life

  • A friend’s good news gives you a small, guilty sting.
  • You find yourself looking for the flaw in someone else’s success.
  • Scrolling social media regularly leaves you feeling worse about your life.
  • You feel relief, even a little pleasure, when someone you envy stumbles.
  • It is easier to support people who are not doing better than you.

Envy vs jealousy

They are often swapped, but they differ. Envy involves two people: you want what someone else has, or want them not to have it. Jealousy involves three: you fear losing something you already have, such as a partner or friend, to a rival. Envy says “I wish I had your life”; jealousy says “I am afraid you will take mine.”

If envy is your top result

A high Envy score often means you are ambitious, observant and surrounded by comparisons, which today usually means a phone. It also means your desires are vivid. Treat envy as data: it points precisely at what you want. The problem begins when you aim at the other person instead of the goal.

The hidden gift

Clarity about desire. What you envy is a precise map of what you actually want, which is useful information.

The shadow

Comparison steals joy from both sides: you cannot enjoy their win, and your own wins never look big enough.

A small practice

Next time envy flashes, turn it into a sentence: “I want ___ too.” Then take one step toward it instead of away from them.

The opposite virtue: kindness

The contrary virtue is kindness (also called brotherly love or benevolence): genuine gladness at the good of others. Buddhism has a name for the feeling, mudita, sympathetic joy in another’s good fortune, and it is the precise reverse of envy.

Envy in Dante, Spenser and demonology

Envy at a glance
Latin nameInvidia
Opposite virtueKindness (Humanitas)
Dante, PurgatorioTerrace 2: eyelids sewn shut with wire
Family of love gone wrongLove bent toward harm
Spenser, The Faerie QueeneRides a wolf
Demon (Binsfeld, 1589)Leviathan

Dante climbs the seven sins as the terraces of a mountain, and envy is terrace 2 of 7. In his scheme it belongs to love bent toward harm: love of self that turns against others. In the House of Pride in Spenser’s Faerie Queene (1590), each sin rides in procession on a symbolic beast. In 1589 the German bishop Peter Binsfeld paired each sin with a demon, a list that still turns up in games, novels and horror films.

Envy FAQ

Why is envy a deadly sin?

Because it turns love of others upside down: instead of wanting good for people, it is pained by their good. Gregory the Great placed it among the capital sins because it breeds others, such as resentment, gossip and delight in someone’s misfortune.

What is the difference between envy and jealousy?

Envy is wanting what another person has. Jealousy is fearing you will lose what you have to someone else. Envy involves two people; jealousy usually involves three.

What is the opposite of envy?

Kindness, in the traditional list of contrary virtues: rejoicing in the good of others rather than resenting it.

The other six deadly sins

Sources

  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1866 (the capital sins)
  2. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II q.36 (Envy)
  3. Gregory the Great, Moralia in Job
  4. Dante, Purgatorio (overview of the seven terraces)
  5. Envy (encyclopedia overview)