Deadly sin VI of VII · Saffron

Gluttony: the deadly sin of gula

One more. Then one more.

Updated · Checked against primary sources

Gluttony (Latin gula) is the deadly sin of over-indulgence in food, drink and, by extension, any consumable pleasure: using comfort to excess or as a refuge. Classical writers said it is not only eating too much but eating too soon, too eagerly, too expensively and too fussily. Its opposite virtue is temperance.

What is the sin of gluttony?

Gluttony was the first of Evagrius’s eight evil thoughts, because the desert monks fasted and felt it first. Gregory the Great described five ways to commit it, which Aquinas repeated: eating too soon, too expensively, too much, too eagerly, or too daintily (in Latin, praepropere, laute, nimis, ardenter, studiose). On Dante’s sixth terrace the gluttonous are starved thin beneath trees laden with fruit and sprayed with clear water they cannot reach.

Signs of gluttony in everyday life

  • “Just one more” covers episodes, snacks, drinks and scrolling.
  • Food or treats are your main reward after a hard day.
  • You eat, drink or watch past the point where it is still enjoyable.
  • You are very particular about having exactly the thing you want.
  • It is hard to leave anything good unfinished.

Gluttony vs enjoyment

Enjoying food, wine or a long binge of a great series is not gluttony; the tradition celebrated feasts. Gluttony begins when pleasure becomes automatic or medicinal: when you consume to soothe, numb or avoid, and keep going after the pleasure has stopped. Note that this is a light-hearted test; if eating or drinking feels out of your control, a doctor or counsellor is the right person to talk to.

If gluttony is your top result

A high Gluttony score usually means you have a real capacity for pleasure and comfort, and that you lean on it when life is stressful. People like you make good hosts and good company. The work is to keep enjoyment conscious, so that comfort stays a choice instead of a reflex.

The hidden gift

A real capacity for joy. You know how to celebrate, host and make ordinary days taste better.

The shadow

When comfort becomes automatic it stops being enjoyment; the second helping is rarely as good as the first.

A small practice

Make one indulgence fully conscious: no screen, no rush, stop at the point where it is still delicious.

The opposite virtue: temperance

The contrary virtue is temperance: the art of enjoying good things in the measure that keeps them good. The ancient Greeks called it sophrosyne, a sound and balanced mind. Temperance does not shrink pleasure; it protects it from turning into habit.

Gluttony in Dante, Spenser and demonology

Gluttony at a glance
Latin nameGula
Opposite virtueTemperance (Temperantia)
Dante, PurgatorioTerrace 6: starve beneath fruit they cannot reach
Family of love gone wrongLove of good things, too much
Spenser, The Faerie QueeneRides a swine
Demon (Binsfeld, 1589)Beelzebub

Dante climbs the seven sins as the terraces of a mountain, and gluttony is terrace 6 of 7. In his scheme it belongs to love of good things, too much: real goods, loved out of measure. In the House of Pride in Spenser’s Faerie Queene (1590), each sin rides in procession on a symbolic beast. In 1589 the German bishop Peter Binsfeld paired each sin with a demon, a list that still turns up in games, novels and horror films.

Gluttony FAQ

Is gluttony only about food?

Originally it was about food and drink, but the same pattern, consuming past the point of enjoyment or to escape, applies naturally to binge-watching, scrolling and shopping, and many modern writers use it that way.

What are the five ways of gluttony?

Gregory the Great and Thomas Aquinas listed eating too soon, too expensively, too much, too eagerly, and too daintily or fussily.

What is the opposite of gluttony?

Temperance: moderation that keeps pleasure in proportion.

The other six deadly sins

Sources

  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1866 (the capital sins)
  2. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II q.148 (Gluttony, including the five ways in article 4)
  3. Evagrius Ponticus and the eight evil thoughts
  4. Dante, Purgatorio (overview of the seven terraces)
  5. Gluttony (encyclopedia overview)