Deadly sin II of VII · Gold leaf

Greed: the deadly sin of avaritia

The feeling that there is never quite enough.

Updated · Checked against primary sources

Greed, or avarice (Latin avaritia), is the deadly sin of wanting more than you need, especially money and possessions, and holding on to them beyond reason. It is a sin of excess: the good of security, loved out of measure. Its opposite virtue is generosity (liberality, sometimes called charity).

What is the sin of greed?

Avarice appears on the earliest list, Evagrius Ponticus’s eight evil thoughts, as philargyria, love of silver, echoing 1 Timothy 6:10, “the love of money is the root of all evil”. Later medieval preachers, writing as trade and money spread, came to treat it as the vice that most corrupts a society. In Dante’s Purgatorio the avaricious lie face down on the ground, bound hand and foot: in life they kept their eyes on earthly things, so now they can see nothing else. Notably, Dante punishes the wasteful spenders on the same terrace, because both misuse wealth.

Signs of greed in everyday life

  • The figure that would count as “enough” keeps moving up.
  • You know exactly who owes whom, to the cent.
  • Giving something away triggers a quick mental calculation of its value.
  • You keep things “just in case” long after they are useful.
  • Free time feels wasted unless it earns or saves something.

Greed vs ambition

Ambition wants to build or achieve something, and money can be a tool for it. Greed wants accumulation for its own sake, and especially to stop the anxiety of not having enough. A simple test: ambition can be satisfied by reaching a goal; greed moves the goal as soon as you arrive.

If greed is your top result

A high Greed score usually reflects a need for security and control, often learned from a time when resources were scarce. It makes you prudent and good at planning. The risk is that the hoard becomes the point, and the people and experiences it was meant to serve get postponed.

The hidden gift

Foresight. You plan, you protect your people from scarcity, and you rarely waste anything.

The shadow

“Enough” never arrives, and holding on can cost you the experiences and the people the resources were meant for.

A small practice

Give away one thing you could have sold, or pay for something without checking the price first, and sit with how it feels.

The opposite virtue: generosity

The contrary virtue is generosity, also called liberality: the free, glad use of what you have for others. Aristotle placed it as the mean between stinginess and wastefulness, which is exactly the pairing Dante punishes together.

Greed in Dante, Spenser and demonology

Greed at a glance
Latin nameAvaritia
Opposite virtueGenerosity (Liberalitas)
Dante, PurgatorioTerrace 5: lie face down, bound to the ground
Family of love gone wrongLove of good things, too much
Spenser, The Faerie QueeneAvarice, riding a camel
Demon (Binsfeld, 1589)Mammon

Dante climbs the seven sins as the terraces of a mountain, and greed is terrace 5 of 7. In his scheme it belongs to love of good things, too much: real goods, loved out of measure. In the House of Pride in Spenser’s Faerie Queene (1590), each sin rides in procession on a symbolic beast. In 1589 the German bishop Peter Binsfeld paired each sin with a demon, a list that still turns up in games, novels and horror films.

Greed FAQ

Is greed the same as avarice?

Yes. Avarice (Latin avaritia) is the traditional name of the sin; greed is the everyday English word for it. Older lists sometimes use covetousness for the same thing.

What is the opposite of greed?

Generosity, also called liberality or charity. It answers greed by treating possessions as something to use and share rather than to hoard.

Is wanting money a sin?

Not in the classical sense. Earning, saving and providing for others are not avarice. The sin is an inordinate love of wealth: wanting it beyond need, at the cost of justice or of people.

The other six deadly sins

Sources

  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1866 (the capital sins)
  2. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II q.118 (Covetousness)
  3. 1 Timothy 6:10 (KJV)
  4. Dante, Purgatorio (overview of the seven terraces)
  5. Greed (encyclopedia overview)